Open Whistle

Same standard, both sides of the whistle.

World Rugby holds coaches to a strict standard when they speak about officiating. We’re asking it to hold officiating itself to an equally visible standard.

Why now

Since July 2026, World Rugby has been sanctioning coaches under a new Match Official Abuse Sanction Process. Its bans take effect immediately, before any hearing.

Italy coach Gonzalo Quesada was the first, with a two-match ban in July for comments after a defeat to New Zealand. On 17 November 2026, South Africa coach Rassie Erasmus was suspended for six international matches over comments about officiating in a match against France, and a full hearing has been requested. Around the same time, a Hong Kong China coaching staff member received a six-match ban under the same process for verbal abuse of match officials.

World Rugby is right to protect match officials from abuse and threats. But at a time when a coach from any country can be removed from his team for questioning decisions, there is still no public way to see how those decisions were reviewed. That imbalance is what this petition is about.

  • This is not a petition to clear any individual. The disciplinary process will run its course.
  • It does not name or criticise any referee. It asks for a better system around them.

World Rugby’s own commitments

Everything we ask for is already promised, in principle, in World Rugby’s own documents. What’s missing is visible delivery.

Its values

World Rugby names five core values, with integrity defined as honesty and fair play.

  • Integrity
  • Respect
  • Solidarity
  • Passion
  • Discipline

Its 2026–31 strategy

The new strategic plan, built around powering rugby, uniting the game and enriching lives, lists this as a key action under the shape of the game:

“Bring clarity and consistency through match officiating and law application.”

Its disciplinary rules

Regulation 18 opens by placing a general obligation on all stakeholders to uphold the integrity of the game. That duty is not limited to players and coaches.

Its TMO protocol

The TMO protocol in force from 1 July 2026 says the TMO exists to help protect the integrity of the game through accurate decisions on clear and obvious foul play and try-scoring situations.

Why only World Rugby can fix this. World Rugby’s Code of Conduct prohibits unions and team staff from publishing criticism of how a match official handled a match. Coaches can’t make the case in public. If transparency is going to exist, it has to come from World Rugby itself.

What’s already in place, and what isn’t

Before asking for anything, we checked World Rugby’s regulations, protocols and statements to make sure we weren’t demanding something that already exists.

Public officiating reviews

Not in place
What exists

Matches are reviewed internally, and World Rugby has occasionally admitted errors in public, such as a late penalty in Scotland v Australia in 2015 and the opening weekend of the 2019 World Cup.

What’s missing

In 2023 World Rugby stated it does not publicly comment on match official decisions. Reviews stay private unless they leak.

A published TMO protocol

In place
What exists

The TMO protocol is public, with defined review windows and the laws each review covers.

What’s missing

There is no public reporting on how consistently it is applied. Our ask is about reporting on its use, not publishing it.

A channel for teams to raise concerns

Partly in place
What exists

Since July 2026, coaches can submit up to six clips after a match, visible to all coaches and referees. Pre-match meetings with the referee happen only if both coaches agree and attend together.

What’s missing

Outcomes aren’t published. Supporters can’t see whether any concern was upheld.

Visible accountability for officials

Not in place
What exists

Performance reviews and appointment decisions happen behind closed doors.

What’s missing

No published standard or outcome, in contrast to coach sanctions, which are announced publicly.

A range of sanctions for coaches

Partly in place
What exists

Regulation 18 already allows cautions, warnings, reprimands, fines and other options. The new process ranges from no action to a guidance letter, a formal warning or an automatic sanction.

What’s missing

In practice, the automatic sanction has meant match-day bans: two matches for Quesada and six for Erasmus. The team and its supporters carry the cost.

A published sanction scale

Not in place
What exists

Panels use a decision-making matrix that grades comments from no action up to an automatic suspension. The timing of comments counts against the coach.

What’s missing

Neither the matrix nor the ban lengths it produces have been published, so nobody can check whether two matches for one coach and six for another are consistent. The effect of a ban on the next match isn’t a stated factor.

A hearing before a sanction

Partly in place
What exists

Under the standard Regulation 18 route, a misconduct complaint goes to an independent judicial committee and must be proved first. Under the new process, a full hearing can be requested.

What’s missing

The fast-track sanction takes effect immediately, so a coach can miss matches before being heard.

What we ask

We call on World Rugby to:

  1. Publish a post-match officiating review for every international Test.Include acknowledged errors, as World Rugby has done in exceptional cases before.
  2. Report publicly on how the TMO protocol is applied.At least once a season: how many reviews, how many decisions changed, and acknowledged misses.
  3. Publish the outcomes of the post-match clip process.And allow more than six clips in Test matches, where the stakes are highest.
  4. Set a visible accountability standard for match officials.As clear and public as the standard applied to coaches.
  5. Use the full range of sanctions already in Regulation 18.Prefer fines, warnings and non-match-day restrictions for coaches, so players and supporters aren’t punished for one person’s words.
  6. Publish the decision-making matrix and sanction scale.So every union and supporter can see how ban lengths are decided, and whether they’re applied consistently.
  7. Hear people before sanctioning them.Anyone facing a suspension should have the chance to be heard before it takes effect.

We also call on every World Rugby member union to formally table these proposals at the World Rugby Council, and to make its support for the fast-track sanction process conditional on matching transparency.

Fair questions

Isn’t this just about defending Rassie?

No. Comments that question an official’s honesty can fuel abuse, and World Rugby is right to act on abuse. This petition is about the system around those comments, and it would apply equally to every coach and every union.

Won’t publishing reviews expose referees to more abuse?

World Rugby’s own monitoring has found that much online abuse starts with inaccurate comments about refereeing. Accurate, official reviews are the best answer to inaccurate claims. Reviews would cover decisions, not people’s character.

Why can’t coaches just raise this themselves?

The Code of Conduct prohibits them from publishing criticism of how an official handled a match, and the private clip process doesn’t report outcomes. That leaves supporters as the only voice able to ask in public.

Didn’t the unions agree to the new process?

Yes. It was introduced with the support of member unions, competitions, and the international bodies for match officials and players. We’re asking that strict sanctions on speech be matched by equally strict transparency on officiating.

Fans pay a lot to watch. Why does that matter?

Supporters spend heavily on tickets and travel to watch both teams compete at full strength. Removing a head coach on match day changes the contest they paid for. Sanctions should hold the individual accountable without taking that away.

Add your name

Respect for referees and accountability for refereeing aren’t opposites. A game that’s confident in its officials should welcome both.

Petition link coming soon

The petition is hosted on Change.org. This site doesn’t collect any personal information.